The Barometer's Secret

1. Theory: Why Most Traders Misread the RSI

J. Welles Wilder introduced the Relative Strength Index in June 1978. Every charting platform includes it with identical defaults: 14 periods, 0–100 scale, closing price input. This ubiquity has created a paradox: because everyone has the RSI, everyone misuses it.

Hayden's central argument is that traders treat the RSI as a simple overbought/oversold tool without understanding its internal logic. The result is a generation of traders who sell overbought rallies in strong trends and buy oversold declines in bear markets — exactly the wrong thing to do.

2. The Formula and Its Memory

The RSI is computed in two stages:

Because of this exponential smoothing, the RSI requires at least 10×N bars (ideally 20×N) to stabilize. For a 14-period RSI, that means 140–280 bars of history before the values are reliable. Traders who begin trading immediately after the first 14 bars are using distorted signals.

3. The Secret: Logarithmic Behavior

Here is Hayden's non-obvious insight, and the heart of the barometer's secret: the RSI does not increase linearly.

Table #3 in Hayden's book reveals that the largest value jumps occur when the gain/loss ratio moves from 1:1 to 2:1 (RSI moves from 50 to 66.67 — a 16.67-point gain). Moving from 2:1 to 3:1 only adds 8.33 points. To reach RSI 80, a 4:1 ratio is required — a rare condition in most markets.

Implication: A price move that barely changes the RSI near 80 is not weak momentum. It is the mathematical ceiling of the formula. Conversely, large RSI moves near 50 indicate significant shifts in the underlying gain/loss balance. The RSI is most sensitive between 40 and 60 — exactly where most traders pay the least attention.

4. The 50 Level: True Equilibrium

The 50 level is the point where average gains equal average losses (the 1:1 ratio). When RSI rallies from below 50 to above 50, it is bullish confirmation. When it crosses below 50, it is bearish confirmation.

Unlike the arbitrary 70/30 zones, the 50 level is structural. It often acts as support in uptrends and resistance in downtrends. However, Hayden warns: It pays to notice when the RSI crosses 50, but this should not be our main focus while trading!

5. RSI Chart Formations

RSI values can form classical patterns — triangles, pennants, double tops and bottoms, head and shoulders — that are invisible on the price chart. Trendlines drawn on the RSI have the same validity as trendlines on price.

The most common pattern is the triangle, which often precedes an explosive move. Hayden's critical caveat: However, there is often a false breakout before the real move!

6. Signal Cards: RSI Modifications

Hayden reviews four common RSI modifications in Section II. His verdict on all of them: useful as filters after mastery, but dangerous as primary methodologies.

7. Common Mistakes

• Treating RSI as linear. Expecting equal point moves at all levels ignores the logarithmic reality.
• Trading before stabilization. The first 10×N bars are unreliable due to exponential initialization.
• Using 70/30 as primary signals. In strong trends, RSI can remain above 70 for extended periods. See Navigating the Reefs.
• Ignoring the 50 level. While not an entry trigger, it is the most mathematically significant level on the oscillator.

Related Guides